Case Update (2020): Trott v. Trott; Hague Abduction Convention, comity to a Hague order from foreign jurisdiction
In the case of Trott v. Trott, the Eastern District of New York granted a father's petition to have his two daughters returned to Bermuda. The parties are parents to two daughters. Their eldest child is not the father's biological daughter, but was raised as his daughter. The youngest is his biological daughter. The children had lived in Bermuda since they were young, but, moved to New York with their mother, without objection by their father (despite a Bermudian ne exeat order being in place) in 2013. During a visit to Bermuda in 2018, the children alerted their father to what amounted to abuse and neglect by their mother. The father refused to return the girls to New York, and their mother pursued a Hague Abduction return petition in the Berumdian courts. The trial court examined whether it would be a grave risk of harm to return the children, ultimately concluded it would not, and asked the parties to identify protective measures available in New York ...